Reviews
In Presidents and Their Generals , Matthew Moten sets out to provide an episodic history of what he calls American 'political-military relations,' by which he means the relationship between military leaders and their civilian overseers. He succeeds admirably, jumping from the Revolution through the War of 1812 to the Civil War, the two World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, the 1991 Gulf War, and the Iraq war. This book is well done: Well considered, well structured, and well written. Moten, a former head of West Point's history department, is a clear and pleasant writer, with an assured style. He favors making bold statements and then backing them up with persuasive analyses... Moten is sophisticated in his political analysis in a way that academics sometimes are not... The most surprising thing about this book may be that no one seems to have written one like it until now. Moten has stepped up and filled the gap impressively., A new and welcome exploration of the often fraught interactions between political and military authority in the United States from the Revolution to the present. Moten makes clear that all was not orderly in the councils of national defense during the last two centuries, and that they are likely to grow even more contentious in the future., [Moten] traces the long struggle of presidents to assert their power over recalcitrant generals... Moten beautifully exposes the battles and the alliances between men controlling the country's future... The author explains the workings of war, the effects and dangers of standing armies, and the growth of the president's Cabinet-level military advisers... The author's opinions are precise and witty and based on comprehensive knowledge of his subject, as he clearly demonstrates how wars are lost by the arrogant and/or incompetent. A brilliant, fascinating picture of how wars badly begun and poorly run can affect an entire country--usually at the hands of just a few men., In a country as disposed to war as the United States has been, the relationship between the commander in chief and his admirals and generals is as critical as that between the president and Congress. Just how critical that relationship may be is the theme of this book, the first full-length history of its subject. It should be required reading in the White House, the Pentagon, and Foggy Bottom--in this, and every succeeding administration. The history it relates is sobering. Matthew Moten is the kind of authority you'd want for a guide through the subject: As the former head of West Point's history department, an Iraq war veteran, and a former legislative aide to the Army chief of staff, he has the broad field and staff experience essential for understanding political-military relations in their many forms--and from inside. He's thorough, disenthralled, critical, and balanced in his judgments. No one can dismiss what he writes... Presidents and Their Generals makes a signal contribution to the historical knowledge of its subject over the long sweep of our nation's history., [ Moten ] traces the long struggle of presidents to assert their power over recalcitrant generals... Moten beautifully exposes the battles and the alliances between men controlling the country's future... The author explains the workings of war, the effects and dangers of standing armies, and the growth of the president's Cabinet-level military advisers... The author's opinions are precise and witty and based on comprehensive knowledge of his subject, as he clearly demonstrates how wars are lost by the arrogant and/or incompetent. A brilliant, fascinating picture of how wars badly begun and poorly run can affect an entire country--usually at the hands of just a few men., A new and welcome exploration of the often fraught interactions between political and military authority in the United States from the Revolution to the present . Moten makes clear that all was not orderly in the councils of national defense during the last two centuries, and that they are likely to grow even more contentious in the future.
