RARE Byers Choice Caroler Halloween Salem Witch With Cat On Bench Signed

When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

RARE Byers Choice Caroler Halloween Salem Witch With Cat On Bench Signed:
$374.95

RARE Byers Choice Caroler Halloween “Salem Witch with Cat on Bench” – Signed 2010

This delightful and hard-to-find Byers Choice Halloween Caroler captures the playful, whimsical spirit of the season. The hand-painted witch sits thoughtfully on a wooden bench, holding a crinkled map and broom, accompanied by her loyal black cat wearing a candy-corn hat. Each detail — from the candy-patterned skirt to the expressive papier-mâché face — showcases the signature charm of Byers Choice craftsmanship.

Every Byers Choice figure is handcrafted in Chalfont, Pennsylvania, with individually sewn clothing and unique, hand-painted features — no two are ever exactly alike. This piece comes signed and dated 2010, adding collectible value and authenticity.

Height: approximately 9.5" tall x 6" wide

Condition & Notes

Pre-owned. The witch figure is in excellent overall condition.
The black cat has a small chip on one ear and minor paint wear/chipping on the base. The cat figure also needs to be glued back onto the bench — you can choose to reattach it or display it separately in any position you prefer. These small issues are subtle and not distracting when displayed.

Overall, the set remains charming, collectible, and display-ready. Please review all photos carefully, as they are part of the description.

Because these figures are vintage and handcrafted from mixed materials, they may show light age-related wear typical of Byers Choice pieces — such as slightly aged fabrics, light dust in folds, or gentle fading from display.

Due to the handmade nature of this brand, small accessories like hats, brooms, or ribbons may shift slightly over time. A bit of natural variation or looseness is normal and not considered damage.

Perfect For

Whether you’re expanding your Byers Choice collection or discovering them for the first time, this signed Halloween piece makes a delightful seasonal addition. It also serves as a thoughtful gift for collectors who appreciate traditional American craftsmanship and festive charm.

Each Byers Choice Caroler tells its own story — of celebration, nostalgia, and artistry — making this witch and cat duo a treasured accent that brings warmth and personality to any home during the Halloween season.

Please see the photos as they are part of the description :)